Ahavah Ehyeh (ahavah) wrote,
Ahavah Ehyeh

An Echo in the Bone, by Diana Gabaldon

An Echo in the Bone, by Diana Gabaldon

Echo in the Bone

I finished this a week ago, and I've had trouble coming up with a rating or a review. I usually like Gabaldon's writing for the most part, but this book was a disappointment. I think I've got to go with another 2-star here.

It's obvious that she did her research, but a lot of stuff seems to just be thrown in to get to show off said research and didn't make a lot of sense plotwise. In fact, I found many passages to be confusing in this installment, and many others were just plain dull and didn't seem to serve the story. I agree that she was using too many viewpoint characters in this one. So we have a looooong book with random stuff happening across different times, but very little is actually accomplished...including a satisfying ending. There were several cliffhangers left unresolved, and the book just stopped rather abruptly.

I thought the book before this one was getting better, so Echo seems even more lackluster by comparison. Claire & co. get swept along by history, but I wish they had a bit more agency and weren't just floating around like flotsam. This is an obvious bridge to the next book that doesn't stand alone as a satisfying novel.
Tags: books, reviews

  • Wolfenoot

    A friend of mine has a son who had the most wonderful idea. He has created a new holiday called Wolfenoot (wolf-a-noot). From their page: It is when…

  • I'm Not a Fall Person

    It looks like I haven't done a real update since April, and I've not done any book reports since February. I'm definitely not going to make my NYR…

  • December Blogging Meme Masterpost 2017

    I'm stealing this December meme from dreamwriteremmy - Pick a date in December and give me something to talk about. - You don't have to be…

  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.